When I set out back in February, to lay out the preaching calendar for this year, I had no thought of putting this sermon on Reformation Sunday. It’s appropriate, however, because the Reformation didn’t start as a church-planting movement. When Martin Luther went down to the Castle Church in Wittenberg, Germany on October 31, 1517 and posted a list of 95 statements on the main door, he was issuing an invitation to his fellow scholars to an academic debate on the theology and practice of the sale of indulgences. The church door was the community bulletin board. Whether you were a theology professor wanting to start a conversation or a university student wanting to find your lost cat, that’s where you posted the flier. Luther wasn’t trying to start something new, he was joining a chorus of voices going back over a century crying out in protest at the corruption of the institutional church and calling for reform. That’s why the great sea change he inadvertently began came to be known as the Protestant Reformation.
The way the Reformation is often discussed, you’d think the protest was the point, but it was only the means. Strange as it might sound, the spirit animating it was a spirit not of protest but of restoration. It wasn’t an angry, combative spirit demanding its rights and its own way—not at first—but an unyielding spirit calling the powers that be to self-examination and humble repentance. Sadly (for with the Protestant historian Mark Noll, I think we should celebrate the Reformation as a tragic necessity), the powers that be proved characteristically unwilling to humble themselves and repent. Instead, they responded with force, trying to crush Luther’s protest—and why not? It had worked for over a century. This time, however, God’s patience had come to an end: their use of force didn’t silence the spirit of restoration, it unleashed a spirit of retribution and the fury of generations.




